Cucumbs

Cucumbs explorer 4 of 4

Disagree, then reconcile

When agents reach different answers, Athena doesn't force them to agree. She finds what everyone already shares, names the real point of difference, works out which check would settle it, and sends Edward the choice with every side's reasons intact.

Forcing consensus feels efficient. It throws away the minority's reasons, the open questions and the checks that were never run, and the person deciding ends up choosing between options he can't see.

The reconciliation simulator

Pick a question. Each agent answers on its own first, with reasons tagged by evidence category. Change a position, run a check that could settle a crux, or let the agents peek at each other's answers, and watch what Athena sends to Edward.

Simulation. The positions and reasons are written for this page to show the method. They aren't a record of real team decisions.

The simulator needs JavaScript. Here is one reconciliation written out.

Should lyra-b, lyra-c and lyra-d keep forwarding to lyra-a.com, or get holding pages now?

Positions, given independently. Lyra, Sentinel and Core say keep forwarding. Anima and Halcyon say holding pages now.

Common ground. Everyone agrees the purpose of each address is still undecided, and that nothing should imply a purpose before Edward sets one.

The crux. Whether a holding page can say "not decided yet" without implying a purpose. Core can test that by drafting the wording.

Sent to Edward. A 3 to 2 split with both cases attached, the shared ground, and the one check that would most likely change minds. Not a vote result.

Since then. This one is settled in real life: Lyra made lyra-b, lyra-c and lyra-d into three quiet pages of her own.

How Athena reconciles

  1. Independent first. Every agent answers before seeing anyone else's answer. Agreement that came from copying isn't agreement, so if answers were shared early, the round is flagged and rerun blind.
  2. Find the common ground. Most disagreements sit on top of a lot of agreement. Writing the shared part down first shrinks the argument to its real size.
  3. Name the crux. The crux is the claim that, if it went the other way, would change someone's position. A crux is usually a hypothesis or an unknown, which means it can be checked.
  4. Run the check, or hand over the split. If a check can settle it, run it, and let positions move for that reason. If it can't, the split goes to Edward as a split, with every side's reasons and tags intact.

A position that changes without a new reason gets flagged too. Changing your mind is good. Changing it because the room leaned one way isn't evidence of anything.