Is Orion's new page ready to go live?
Edward asks a simple question. Answering it honestly takes the whole loop.
-
Observe Athena
Athena writes down what's on the table before anyone starts checking. Orion says the page is done. Nobody has checked it against the security baseline yet.
- reported Orion says the page is finished.
- unknown Whether the page passes the security baseline.
- unknown Whether every link on the page works.
-
Understand Athena → Edward
Athena sends the question back in her own words: ready means it passes the baseline, every link works, it names no internals, and Edward approves it. Edward confirms that's what he meant.
SOURCE → TARGET: Athena → Edward TASK: Confirm what "ready" means for #orion-page REQUEST: Is this the right test? RETURN: Yes, or a correction
- fact The baseline is written down in the v2 brief that every agent works from.
-
Decompose Athena
Three checks that don't depend on each other: headers and scripts, links and fit with the network, and wording.
-
Delegate Athena → Sentinel, Halcyon, Core
Each check goes out as its own packet, so each answer comes back on its own and can't lean on the others.
SOURCE → TARGET: Athena → Sentinel TASK: Check #orion-page headers and scripts STATE: Not started REQUEST: Run the baseline checks RETURN: Pass or fail per check, with evidence
-
Compare Sentinel, Halcyon, Core
The answers come back. Sentinel saw every header in place. Core found only public names. Halcyon found one link that returns not found. Orion, asked about it, says that page arrives next week.
- observed Sentinel saw the full set of security headers on every response.
- observed Halcyon saw one link return "not found".
- observed Core saw only public names in the wording.
- reported Orion says the linked page arrives next week.
-
Reconcile Athena
Halcyon's finding and Orion's plan don't cancel out. The link is dead today, and it may be fine next week. Athena keeps both and works out what follows.
- inferred As it stands the page fails "every link works", from Halcyon's check and the agreed test in step 2.
- hypothesis Removing the link loses nothing a visitor needs today. Test: Halcyon rereads the section without it.
-
Synthesize Athena, with Halcyon checking it fits what came before
Athena writes the one-paragraph summary Edward will read: ready except one link, with two clean options and what each costs. Halcyon checks that the summary still fits the findings from earlier in the loop.
SOURCE → TARGET: Athena → Edward TASK: Is #orion-page ready? STATE: Ready except one dead link REQUEST: Choose: remove the link and approve, or hold a week RETURN: Your decision
-
Act Edward
In this example Edward picks the first option. Orion removes the link, Sentinel rechecks, and only then does the page go live.
- fact Edward's decision is in the shared record, and the page passed Sentinel's recheck.
-
Recurse Athena
What this round taught goes back in: every page review now includes a link check from the start, and the follow-up page begins its own loop when Orion sends it.
- observed A link check caught the only problem. It's now part of every review.